masterkey logo
417 Gardner Hollow Road
Score
76
Poughquag, NY

417 Gardner Hollow Road

750K
3 bd • 3 ba • 3,264 sf

This analysis was generated on 3/24/2025. It is for entertainment purposes only and should not be considered as real estate or investment advice.

AI Property Analysis

0:00
0:00 / 0:00

Property Overview

List Price
$749,500
+42%vs 12570
Price/Sq.Ft
$230
-19%vs 12570
Above Fair Value
1.3% above range

Current Price

$749,500

Fair Range

$725,000 - $740,000

$749,500
Below Market-20%
Above Market+20%

Negotiation Leverage

3 points to consider in your offer

Recommended Offer

$730,000
Success Probability:High(75%)

AI Rationale

The offer accounts for renovation costs and market conditions. The seller's motivation, due to previous listing issues, supports this strategy.

Overall Score
76
68
Home Condition
75
Natural Light
87
Value
68
Location

Visual Insights

AI-analyzed spaces with reimagining capabilities

Outdated Kitchen Cabinets
Outdated Kitchen Cabinets

Outdated Kitchen Cabinets

The kitchen cabinets are outdated and appear worn.

Weathered Exterior Wood
Weathered Exterior Wood

Weathered Exterior Wood

The exterior wood siding and trim show signs of weathering and could benefit from fresh paint or stain.

Worn Wood Paneling
Worn Wood Paneling

Worn Wood Paneling

Some wood paneling shows signs of wear and could benefit from refinishing or painting.

Renovation Assessment

Prioritized renovations based on property inspection and market impact.

High Priority Renovations

$15,000

Kitchen Renovation

$15,000
High

Note: these are rough estimates. For more accurate estimates, please contact a professional.

Ownership History

Previous ownership changes and transaction details

Jan
2014
$385,000Cash Purchase
January 31, 2014
From:June Levine
To:Jonathan Randall
Deed
Standard Sale (Purchase/Resales)

Pricing History

Historical pricing trends for this property

Monthly Costs

Interactive breakdown of estimated monthly expenses

Monthly Cost
$0123456789012345678901234567890123456789
$749,500
-30%List: $749,500+30%
20%
$149,900of $749,500
7%
1%15%
* Estimates based on a 30-year fixed mortgage. Property tax rate: 1.2%, Home insurance: $1,000/year

Upfront Transaction Costs

Estimated costs due at closing, including down payment and fees

Total Due at Closing
$199,894
Closing Costs
+$49,994
Down Payment
$149,900
Buyer Agent Fee
$19,112
Loan Fees
$5,996
Title & Escrow
$4,498
Inspections
$900
Transfer Tax
$8,245
Prepaid Expenses
$11,243

* Estimated costs based on typical rates. Actual costs may vary by location, lender, and transaction details.

** Buyer agent fees are negotiable and may sometimes be covered by the seller.

Buyer Power Index

5
/10
Limited Buyer Power
Market Speed
0 days
vs 69 day average
This is a new listing, while homes in this area typically sell in 69 days
Inventory Health
6
homes for sale
4 homes sold last month, indicating 1.5x more supply than demand
Price Dynamics
99.3%
of asking price
Homes typically sell for 0.7% below asking price

Price Trajectory

$527,500
Current median price
-16.3%
Year over year
Cooling
Heating
Market favors buyers
Market favors sellers
Market Is heating
Prices are up 2.7% over the last 3 months
3 Months
+2.7%
6 Months
+0.5%
1 Year
-16.3%

Historical Market Pulse

Key metrics over time, revealing market momentum and patterns

Negotiation Insight

Days on market increasing 24.1% over the past 3 months suggests growing buyer leverage.

Historical Comparison
Current Value
$527,500
3 Months Ago
$355,000
+48.6%

Schools

Nearby school quality by education level

Middle

5.0/10
Average

High

7.0/10
Good

Climate Risks

Assessment of climate-related hazards for this property

Moderate Risk Profile

This property has 0 severe, 0 major, and 3 moderate risk factors

Climate risk data is based on historical patterns and projections. Consider consulting with insurance providers and local experts for property-specific assessments.

Sunlight Analysis

Data provided by Shadowmap

Loading sunlight data...

Tour Checklist

Key items to inspect during your property tour

Inspect the oil tank (if visible) for rust, leaks, or signs of age. Note its location (above ground or buried).

Thoroughly inspect the cedar exterior for signs of rot, insect damage (especially near the ground), and proper sealing/staining.

Inspect the basement/crawlspace for signs of moisture, mold, or structural issues.

Questions to Ask

Important questions to ask during the tour

What is the age and condition of the oil tank, and when was it last inspected?

Can you provide documentation of any maintenance or repairs done to the cedar exterior in the past 5 years?

The listing was removed and relisted multiple times. What were the reasons for the previous listing removals?

Showing critical items first. Click any item to see why it's important. Red icons indicate highest priority items that should not be missed.

Property Discussion

Start the Conversation

Share your insights on this property—did you visit the open house? Know of any hidden pros or cons? Your street-level knowledge could be exactly what another buyer needs.

You
Join 1,000+ buyers

Analyze Any Property for Free

Get instant insights and potential savings on any Zillow listing.

Free Analysis
AI-Powered Insights
Instant Results